Welcome to The New Sullivans
The New Sullivans is a delightful spot in Niagara Falls, serving grilled hot dogs, juicy hamburgers, and a variety of hard and soft ice creams. With prices ranging from just $1 to $10, it's perfect for families and budget-conscious diners. The casual atmosphere invites groups and tourists alike, while the scenic creek views add a touch of charm. The menu offers quick bites and comfort food, making it a go-to for both lunch and dinner. Customers love the fast service, especially on sunny days when they can enjoy their meals outdoors. Whether you're in the mood for a classic hot dog with mustard or a refreshing sorbet, this eatery has got you covered!
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Located at 501 Cayuga Drive, The New Sullivans prides itself on being a local hotspot for comfort food. This charming eatery offers a casual and inviting atmosphere, perfect for lunch and dinner crowds. The unique location near a scenic creek makes it perfect for a summer outing with friends or family.
The restaurant features outdoor seating and a spacious dining area for those who prefer to dine in. Wheelchair accessibility ensures that everyone can enjoy a meal here. On a busy Sunday, The New Sullivans can reach full capacity, especially around 5 PM, making it a popular spot for weekend families and tourists. Yet the relaxed vibe keeps it a favorite among locals craving comfort food. The New Sullivans is not just a place to eat; it’s about enjoying good food in a friendly environment.
Parking is convenient with free street and lot parking. With a menu that spans hot dogs, burgers, onion rings, and delicious ice creams, you’ll always find something to satisfy your cravings. If you’re lucky, you might catch some live music or local art on display during your visit, adding to the experience.
Location & Contact
Address
501 Cayuga Dr, Niagara Falls, NY 14304, United States
Hotline
+1 716-205-8288
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
The Sahlens hot dog with fresh-cut fries stands out as a customer favorite, providing a perfect blend of flavor and value at just $6.00.
The french fries consistently receive high praise for their crispness and freshness, hinting at frequently changed oil. Customers rave about the ice cream variety, especially during the hot summer months.
The friendly staff, even during peak times, works to provide a pleasant dining experience, which is recognized by many who visit regularly. The inviting outdoor patio offers a lovely place to enjoy meals while soaking in the surrounding scenery.
Most Disliked
Customers have expressed some frustration with slow service during busy hours, particularly on weekends when the crowd peaks.
Occasional shortages of certain menu items, such as fries, leave diners wanting more and may require additional wait time. Some reviews indicate that orders occasionally get mixed up, leading to a bit of disappointment, although most patrons are understanding of occasional slips in a busy kitchen.
The self-service condiment station could use some attention, as missing items can lead to confusion, especially for first-time visitors unfamiliar with the setup.
Reviews
Mac K.
Amazing. Same as the old Sullivans- amazinggg!
paul c.
very good 🌭 hotdogs and onion rings wanted fries but they were out,icecream was good, service could be better they were slow and forgot one of my orders but all in all not bad,will probably go back again.
E
Have a taste for a hotdog but you dont want to grill. You can get a Sahlens hotdog and fresh cut fries for $6.00. If you want ketchup and mustard it's in the back. You can put it on yourself. I actually recommend it.
Allison K.
The french fries are excellent--I can tell they change the oil often. They're near my house and it's walking distance which is just perfect on a summer day when I'm craving ice cream. ♥️
John G.
Great burgers and fries on a scenic creek. Friendly staff even when overwhelmed, clean and a great value.
Brian M.
It was my first time but not my last. Enjoy the atmosphere and food.
Jimmy S.
Everything about this place is wonderful! The food is delicious, the staff is friendly! Wish I could give Sullivan’s more than 5 stars! Such a great place! Plus you can’t beat Perry’s Ice cream for dessert!